This is a tale that revolves around class, poverty, opportunities and the use of athletics to escape to a better life. The story is from Mumbai, but if race were added in, it could have been in the United States.
The book is about two young boys from Mumbai whose father raises them to be
the very best cricket players in the world. You know where that is going. They are both his hope of sports glory, which eluded him, and getting out of poverty.
Cricket is, of course, a wonderful way of writing about shattered dreams
– both personal and national. As such, it isn’t necessary to know the
game to appreciate this finely told, often moving and intelligent novel.
Cricket here represents what is loved in India, and yet is being
corrupted by the changes within the nation. The nastiness of cricket isn’t only to do with money and
corruption. The book takes in class, religion and sexuality – all
issues that disrupt the dream of a sport that cares for nothing but
talent and temperament. The relationship of the two brothers is
significant but eventually becomes secondary to the one between the
younger boy, Manju, and Javed, a good-looking Muslim from an affluent
family who chooses to walk away from cricket and wants Manju to follow
him. Manju’s attraction to Javed, and his awareness of the barriers
between them, is subtly and often surprisingly explored. In the end we do not know if Manju loves cricket or not, but we do know that it has made him.
There was a period when Tarentino want to be movies was built
around scenes where tough white guys smoke cigarettes, insult each
other and launch into interminable monologues about some aspect of
popular culture until an argument breaks out and everybody points guns
at each other. This is the new but set in the 1970's, and the poster pretty much sums up the situation.
A couple of bright spots are Brie Larson, who stands up to her partners in crime in the gritty shoot out, and Armie Hammer, who is the more intellectual of the criminal element, the guy who cracks a good joke after being shot. It is not as funny as a comedy, there is less action than you would be looking for in an action adventure movie, and yet those two depictions sum up what you are about to see if you watch this.
A couple of bright spots are Brie Larson, who stands up to her partners in crime in the gritty shoot out, and Armie Hammer, who is the more intellectual of the criminal element, the guy who cracks a good joke after being shot. It is not as funny as a comedy, there is less action than you would be looking for in an action adventure movie, and yet those two depictions sum up what you are about to see if you watch this.